Blog Layout

Burning patience and inspiration needed to get us of the highway to climate hell!

Ulrich Graute • 10 November 2022
Art  By lVlorf3us; https://www.deviantart.com/

Keep calm and steady on - while things may get worse, before they become better

We are on a highway to climate hell with our foot still on the accelerator


While the push back of the global pandemic allowed a certain return to pre-corona normality the world is stilled face by developing multiple and interrelated crises including pandemic, climate crisis, wars, inequality etc. Related to this, global goals like the United Nation’s Agenda 2030 with its Sustainable Development Goals SDG, the Paris Agreement with its climate goals or the New Urban Agenda in response to a globally urbanizing world are derailed. In front of this background the UN Secretary-General António Guterres runs from one global conference to the next ringing the alarm bell. At COP27 Summit at Sharm el-Sheikh he said on Monday, 7 November: "We are on a highway to climate hell with our foot still on the accelerator." And “Humanity has a choice: cooperate or perish”. That’s heavy and it seems that everybody agreed more or less.


Assuming that the UN Secretary-General is right with his assessment why aren’t we doing what needs to be done? It seems that too often we still react with fear instead of foresight. We know the general goals but we don’t understand what’s in it for us in the unknown world of sustainability. In a sense it is natural and often it is also appropriate to focus on the fire burning directly in front of you instead of ignoring it and looking for further challenges. And let’s admit, many people are totally consumed by fighting for the immediate survival of their own, their family or group. In day-to-day life, individuals and groups are challenged multiple times and from many sides. Global leaders, national governments, mayors, neighborhood groups, spiritual and cultural leaders, advertisers, friends and family all ask for your support and action on priorities as they see them. In spite of these more or less reasonable requests and suggestions it wouldn’t help if you collapse and are no more available to look for a way of the ‘highway to hell’. Instead, in the interest to keep our eyes focused on the goals we have to keep calm and steady on, while things may get worse, before they become better.


UN Secretary-General António Guterres at the opening of COP 27 on 7 November 2022

Slider Photo Credit: UNFCCC/Kiara Worth

Multiple crises as the new normal: Things may get worse, before they become better

 

I am an optimistic realist and as such I don’t ignore worst case scenarios. Food crises, economic inequality, lack of inclusion and even mental health problems are on the rise and force more and more people to deal with these challenges first. This slows development and innovation on the short term. And of course, current challenges like the war in Ukraine, are they already worst cases? If you think so just consider that Putin may lose the war and warlords of the current war like Ramzan Kadyrov, Yevgeny Prigozhin (Wagner troops), the Russian military, secret services and regional leaders start a power fight ripping apart Russia with its many economic and social problems - and that in a country with many nuclear arms. Thus, even if Ukraine wins problems in the region and world can get worse while at the same time climate change may send us a new wave of disasters. To make things even more worse it doesn’t help that many national governments turn away from multilateralism and chose nationally favorable paths to fight common world problems.

 

As an urban and regional development expert I can imagine what negative side effects such developments could generate in cities and territories but, of course, I cannot really assess the likeliness and impact of above scenarios. However, it is important to recall worst case scenarios because there is no proof at all that the worst point would have been achieved already and that things can get better only. For the time being we should assume and adapt to the option that developing multiple and interrelated crises is the new normal now.  

 

 

Keeping calm and steady on

 

A lot of time, care and education is needed to become a grown-up. Learning and gaining experience are rather lifelong processes and we need to be patient with ourselves. Pressurin doesn’t always help. Corona just recalled the wisdom that without personal health, wellbeing and informed action we’re easily lost in times of crises.

 

When I enter an airplane the cabin crew usually provides security advice including this: When the pressure drops in the cabin, oxygen masks will fall. For that case I’ll be asked to first affix my own mask (!) before I help children and others. That makes sense because if I cannot breathe normally, I have little or no chance to help others. Therefore, thinking and helping first yourself is not necessarily a bad thing for individuals and groups.

 

Thus, I would like to say: Dear reader, in spite of the highway to climate hell we’re on, if you face major personal challenges regarding your individual economic, social situation and wellbeing don’t ignore them. This may prevent you at the moment to get engaged in other fields. On the longer run it is precondition to become even stronger as supporter or even as leader because you learnt how to grow up to challenges. To share an example of my own, since my early years I have an issue with high blood pressure which I inherited from my father and his mother. As a younger man I was ashamed to admit this ‘weakness’ but I learnt to listen to my body and to live more healthy. Thus, thanks to the health challenge I learnt a lot and the gained knowledge and experience helps me to successfully manage even phases of heavy stress. Today, when others get nervous or even panic, I am able to calm down and steady on.

 

Actually, instead of ‘patience’ I prefer talking about ‘burning patience’ to underscore that we need to keep on mind what is at stake at short and longer term for us as individuals and the world at large. If one is just patient, one may lose the sense of urgency and inner fire. And that can make your life quite boring and even dangerous. So, it’s in everybody’s interest if everybody takes care for his or her own needs and to be or become ready to take action for common causes.

 

Certainly, everybody should find a way to invest a maximum of time and efforts possible to get us of the road to climate hell (and other hells). Be it inside or outside the professional life, the help and transformation of everybody’s lifestyle in a more sustainable way is an important first contribution. If you want to do more and make a unique contribution to get us of that road to hell, I have a suggestion for you:

 

Lean back, stimulate your phantasy and write down in a paper or book a narrative for the post crises world. We have the Agenda 2020 and the Paris Agreement but these provide just goals. Their achievement depends on a longer, interrelated and multi stakeholder process with many variables. Thus, the goals don’t tell us much on how our life on earth would be organized and look like once the goals are achieved. We don’t have that inspiring narrative but we need it to motivate the eight billion people on earth to move and to move faster towards climate change adaptation and sustainability. Again, in case you’re not made to become a political fighter or technician on the path to sustainability why don’t you be creative otherwise and inspire us by telling us a motivating story on how to get off the road to hell and on the path to our future.

 

Policies and Governance for Resilient and Sustainable Cities and Regions

by Ulrich Graute 22 January 2025
Source of the picture OpenAI: https://openai.com/index/announcing-the-stargate-project/
by Ulrich Graute 1 January 2025
It was a tremendous privilege in my life to meet Rosalynn and Jimmy Carter for the first time in 1984 (picture) and then again in the summer of 1985 during my internship at Koinonia Farm near Americus, Georgia (USA). Jimmy Carter, who served as the 39th president of the U.S. from 1977 to 1981, died on December 29, 2024, at his home in Plains, Ga. Jimmy Carter was a lifelong farmer who worked with his hands building houses for the poor well into his 90s. I didn't agree with him on all issues (the early 1980s were the time of a new US missile deployment in Germany ordered by Jimmy Carter and a large peace movement against it) but he took the time to discuss it with me and others at Koinonia Farm. That alone was amazing. Even more mind-blowing was that he continued hands-on work on peacebuilding and house renovation for the poor around the world with Habitat for Humanity International well into his 90s. If in my career providing hands-on support became more important than climbing my own career path, this was also due to the example Jimmy Carter gave in the decades after his Presidency. I learned a lot from him about working for peace with humbleness, love, and perseverance. Read more in the New York Times about why Jimmy Carter was known as much for his charity and diplomatic work later in life as he was for his single presidential term, which ended in 1981. https://lnkd.in/d9qxSmTM *. *. *. *. * Note: This post was first published on LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/posts/graute_learning-to-work-hands-on-for-peace-from-activity-7279396908270309376-BBjV?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_desktop
by Ulrich Graute 2 December 2024
In 2024, for the first time since 2000, the Parties to the United Nations Rio Conventions on biodiversity, climate change, and desertification faced a very busy 3 months, moving from large Conferences of Parties (COP) in Cali (Colombia) for biodiversity in October to Baku (Azerbaijan) for climate in November to Riyadh (Saudi Arabia) for desertification in December. On top of this Triple-COP, there was the UN High Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development and the UN Summit of the Future in September in New York (USA) while UN-Habitat held its World Urban Forum in Cairo (Egypt), and let’s not forget the fifth session of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee to develop an international legally binding instrument on plastic pollution, including in the marine environment (INC-5) which ended last weekend in Busan, South Korea. No real breakthroughs were reported but I noticed many promises to double future efforts. There is a lot that can be critically reviewed about the events, eg what’s the purpose of moving approximately 100.000+ delegates, UN staffers, and other participants worldwide if the necessary political will to agree and resources available are insufficient and the outcomes are limited accordingly? But such a critique would be a bit unfair since I don’t know how many new ideas and initiatives were born during those official meetings, side events, and informal chats that might bloom up in upcoming years despite of the multicrises we’re living in. What needs to be criticized is that the UN System is not progressing on its task to implement its many mandates more “synergistically” by targeting policies, programs, and initiatives to jointly address the goals of the Rio Conventions, SDGs, etc. Instead, the conferences referred to each other but worked mainly within their silos. This is not appropriate in a world full of interrelations and interdepensies. Well, no individual or group can follow up on every aspect, and swarm intelligence of conferences with thousands of participants each seems to be no functioning alternative. But what else could be done? To give an example: How about building an AI-based Large Language Model (LLM) trained with the UN Charter, all UN declarations, national and subnational resolutions, regulations, and programmes? AI Agents for the different conventions and agendas should then be asked to coordinate and propose “synergistic” proposals across policy levels. Of course, the use of artificial intelligence should be wisely supervised by a team of AI experts and professionals from all affected fields. I wouldn’t expect AI applications to solve all problems but to better inform decision-makers and UN agencies on integrated scenarios. This could help to increase efficiency, avoid duplicating efforts, and increase the overall problem-solving capacity of the UN. I would be happy to support such work with my governance and development experience across all policy levels. Picture source: https://www.iisd.org/articles/policy-analysis/cop-nature-climate-adaptation-mitigation
by Ulrich Graute 14 November 2024
Since the first climate COP in 1995, the Local Governments and Municipal Authorities (LGMA) Constituency has been representing local and regional governments at the processes under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). The LGMA also represents ISOCARP - International Society of City and Regional Planners and Global Taskforce of Local and Regional Governments. ICLEI - Local Governments for Sustainability acts as the Focal Point of LGMA. The 2015 Paris Agreement marked a turning point, recognizing the essential role of these governments in enhancing Nationally Determined Contributions NDSs and driving transformative climate action. The LGMA is atively present in Baku with a robust agenda, numerous partners, and an esteemed delegation of political leaders representing local and subnational governments. At the center of the presence is the Multilevel Action & Urbanization Pavilion as the global stage for the city and region climate agenda during COP29. The Pavilion brings into focus not only the challenges and needs, but also the accomplishments and commitments of local and subnational actors on climate action. The Pavilion is open from 12 to 22 November in the Blue Zone, Area E, Pavilion I15. We are looking forward to welcoming you at the High-Level Opening on 12 November at 10:00 AM. Please find the agenda of LGMA attached. Please visit also the Youtube channel of ICLEI Global for daily updates https://lnkd.in/dddDCKtA Ulrich Graute - ISOCARP Online Delegate at COP29 and Chair of the ISOCARP Scientific Committee
by Ulrich Graute 19 October 2024
Report on the Urban Conversation on Ethical Use of AI in Urban Planning at the 60th World Planning Congress in Siena, Italy on 11 OCTOBER 2024
by Ulrich Graute 1 October 2024
Date: 11 October 2024 Time: 10:45 - 13:15 Room: Accademie. Fisiocritici Session background and a short description of the Content Cities form the heart of human development and innovation, with 80% of global GDP generated within them and according to the United Nations approximately 56% of the world’s population now live in cities, and likely to reach nearly 70% by 2050. At the same time, the urban world is on a journey to revitalize cities, build new cities for growing populations, to dismantle inequalities, and to create a sustainable urban legacy for future generations. The growth and demands of cities are rapidly changing and looking (or exploring) for new systems and planning tools. In this situation, Artificial Intelligence (AI) provides a transformative potential in managing and planning cities. It can support, analyze, and predict the impact of policy changes, demographic shifts and development plans. AI facilitates a valuable foundation for productive dialogue and constructive debate between municipal authorities, and the public and private sector. AI enables the People-focused city through systems integration and collaborations. Simultaneously, the application of generative AI in the public domain brings a number of risks and pitfalls. To assure an ethical use of the new wave of innovation in planning it is necessary to strike a careful balance between risk mitigation and harnessing its capabilities for public good and resilience. The central concept of modern Artificial Intelligence (AI) is the intelligent agent. As of today, we have limitations to building one general-purpose AI program that does everything, instead AI developers build different types of agent programs for different types of problems and contexts. AI researchers agree that the new wave of innovation will impact all spheres of life and require more actors for future developments of AI. The discussion on the use of AI cannot be left alone to IT programmers and code developers. In this context, the objective of the conversation is to bring together planning practitioners and experts from city-making to discuss the use and potential impact of AI in urban planning and management and the related leadership of ISOCARP in the global dialogue on AI governance and capacity building of planners. Recent examples eg from Australia and Saudi Arabia will be presented along with panel discussions. Session Organizers Dr Ulrich Graute, Chair of the ISOCARP Scientific Committee, Berlin Dr Sunil Dubey, The UNSW Cities Institute, Sydney. 1. Introduction to the theme of the session by Ulrich Graute 2. The making of inclusive, prosperous and sustainable cities and the new challenges and opportunities provided by AI and Data 2.1 The case of Australia - Key note by Dr Sarah Hill, CEO Greater Sydney Commission and Western Parkland City Authority (New South Wales Govt, former) ‘Planning New Cities and Inclusive economic development’ - Western Sydney Aerotropolis – Australia’s 22nd Century City Making through Community, Creativity and Innovation. 2.2 The case of Saudi Arabia (10 min) Progress, Peace & Prosperity 2030 – How Saudi Cities are transforming using data and power of Ai. Dr Sunil Dubey 3. Roundtable Moderation: Ulrich Graute Guiding questions include AI in Urban Planning: Navigating the Intersection of Technology and Values – AI as a technical tool and/or as co-pilot in planning New Cities and inclusive economic development. Including AI in existing planning systems and processes and the requirement eg of a regulatory framework and capacity-building. What shape will AI have on future cities? ISOCARP and the new wave of technological innovation. Panelists: Sarah Hill, Executive Project Director (Public Investment Fund PIF, Saudi Arabia) Eric Huybrecht, Congress Director ISOCARP’s 60th WPC, Institute Paris Region Elisabeth Belpaire, ISOCARP President-Elect Ulrich Graute, Chair of ISOCARP SciCom Sunil Dubey, Smart Cities thought leader. Website of the 60th ISOCARP World Planning Congress https://isocarp.org/activities/60th-wpc-siena-2024/ Website of the Academy of Social Sciences (UK) AI in urban planning: risks and opportunities https://acss.org.uk/publications/ai-in-urban-planning-risks-and-opportunities/
by Ulrich Graute 15 August 2024
Privacy Communicting with AI raises privacy concerns A CV is personal documents including private information you may not want to share with everybody. Therefore, the sending of your CV to somebody (eg as part of an application or business offer) is usually considered as confidential. Using generative AI, for instance ChatGPT, to work on your CV, website or LinkedIn profile should be carefully considered because the info you share about yourself with ChatGPT stays with ChatGPT even if you delete it from your account after you finished your conversation. Nonetheless, I decided to take it easier using AI because my profile and CV is no secret in anyway. Through dozens of publications since the 1990s, speeches at many conferences worldwide, as blogger with an own website (www.ugraute.de) and a LinkedIn profile with close to 6000 followers you can find everything what’s written in my CV somewhere on the internet. And, most importantly, I carefully review everything that AI suggests to me, I review and finalize texts before I use them. While I cannot fully exclude misuse of information, the responsibility for the content of my website and CV remains with me. And I still use a CV version not aided by AI for business offers and applications. AI as a second eye - When should you consider using AI to review your CV and profile? After 16 years of mostly (but not only) working for the United Nations I am now shifting more attention beyond the UN to the private sector, national and local authorities, other international organizations, NGOs etc. All UN agencies have their own mandates, interests and priorities. As UN staffer and later as UN consultant I learnt the rules of the institution and lived with the limitations they generate for management and goal achievement. However, the UN, with its historical baggage of countless mandates, inadequate structures and resources and some overly cautious employees, at times stands in its own way. I want to continue supporting global cooperation using my global perspective, my skills in project and program management, cross-cultural communication, policy analysis and stakeholder cooperation. However, it is time to refocus and look at my skills and achievements from a different, a non-UN perspective. This is where AI comes into play as an additional opportunity to support the reorientation of my or your career. AI supports my own reflections on my interests and strategy and it does it in a very inspirational way. I recommend the same to others but, if possible, it should be only an opportunity in addition to exchange with friends, colleagues, books, trainers, coaches etc. How did I use Chat GPT to review my website and CV? ChatGPT is a conversational tool, and it’s for free in its basic version. You can login here: https://chatgpt.com/auth/login. After opening an account and login you find a box where you can enter you question (called prompt). You push Enter and get an answer within seconds. If the answer is not inspirational, correct or satisfying you just go on submitting a new or modified prompt. This way conversations with ChatGPT becomes conversational and easy. In this process ChatGPT gets to know you better and learns from your prompts. Prompting, ie formulating the right questions is key to get useful answers out of the conversation and it’s worth to spend some time training how to prompt. In my case, an earlier prompt submitted to ChatGPT had produced already this suggestion: “Adjust your communication style to match the language and expectations of non-UN clients, avoiding overly technical or UN-specific jargon.” That was the point when ChatGPT confirmed my own guess that I have to change communication when I look beyond the UN world. To further explore this, I submitted additional prompts including this one: “ChatGPT, please rewrite my CV in a style more appealing to private companies.” The answer after my own review and fine tuning produced the short CV version which you can find here: https://www.ugraute.de/bio-and-cv Could I have produced this without AI? Of course, I have produced two pages versions of my CV on my own. The point is, that many things which are super important at the UN as “ an animal of its own kind ” are not so relevant outside of the UN. In such situations it may take a lot of time to decide what to leave in and what to take out of your CV. A second eye like AI proposing specific cuts and a repackaging can be very inspirational and helpful to get a fresh and crispier look at your own experience and credentials. I also liked very much that ChatGPT explained its approach to me: “To make your CV more appealing to private companies, I'll focus on making the language more dynamic, emphasizing your key achievements, leadership roles, and strategic impact. I'll also streamline the format for clarity and brevity.” Of course, I reviewed the suggested version of my CV and other website texts revised by AI to confirm the correctness of the content. Overall, this review exercise is a test to use a new technical tool. It is certainly inspirational. Success remains to be seen but that is also the case when I review my CV for an application or if I review my website in a traditional way. I decided for an open approach to use AI and to talk about my personal experience in this post, because in this new wave of innovation, we are all learners and can help each other. As adviser, I like to share, teach, and keep learning, inside or outside of the UN.
by Ulrich Graute 8 August 2024
Figure: Human-in-the-loop intervention. ‘The Ethical Concerns of Artificial Intelligence in Urban Planning’ Thomas W. Sanchez, Marc Brenman, and Xinyue Ye (2024)
by Ulrich Graute 3 August 2024
Human Compatible - AI and the Problem of Control
by Ulrich Graute 9 July 2024
A slide from the UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UN DESA) presented at the opening of HLPF highlights that only 17% of the SDG targets are on track
More posts

Contact Ulrich Graute

Share by: